Jimmy Hays Steakhouse Long Beach

4310 Austin Blvd, Island Park, NY 11558
Call 516-431-1795 Add Review

Delivers: No    Rating: Excellent    Price range: $$$$    Style: American  Reviews    Directions



Daily Soup

Lobster Bisque

Maryland Crab Cakes
over alumette potatoes with roasted red peppers and corn salsa

Shrimp Scampi Casserole
with roasted garlic and lemon herb demi glace

Colossal Lump Crabmeat Cocktail

Clams on the Half Shell (cold)

Baked Middle Neck Clams

Baked Blue Point Oysters(12)

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail (4)

Fried Calamari
with marinara sauce

Zucchini Fritti
with marinara sauce

Shi-Ta-Ke Mushrooms
sauteed over warm leaf spinach with a mushroom demi glace

Roasted Garlic Bread
with gorgonzola sauce

Slab of Apple Wood Smoked Bacon
two slices

Veal Meatball Encasserole

Available at the bar Sunday through Friday

All served with homemade French Fries

Jimmy Hays Steak Sandwich
Sliced filet mignon topped with sautéed vidalia onions and melted fontina cheese served on toasted garlic bread

Mc Cluskey's Bar Burger
Ground porterhouse steak served with lettuce, tomato and white onion (cheese- additional )

Filet Mignon Sliders
Three sliced filet mignon sandwiches topped with bearnaise served on Martin potato rolls

Crab Cake Sandwich
A play on our famous crab cakes served with apple wood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce served on a Martin potato roll

Grilled Chicken Paillard Sandwich
Served with apple smoked bacon, tomato, melted crumbled bleu cheese and lemon herb mayonnaise

Open Faced Steak Sandwich
Sliced filet mignon topped with jalapeno, onion and melted fontina cheese served on lightly toasted garlic bread

Veal Meatball Sliders
Three homemade veal meatballs topped with a veal demi glaze served on Martin Potato rolls


Lobster Thermidor
De-shelled 1 1/2 pound steamed lobster sauteed in a lobster mushroom cream sauce with fresh herbs topped with Parmesan cheese and baked until golden brown

The Skewer
Shrimp, chicken, filet mignon and red & green bell peppers served over broiled tomatoes and Vidalia onions with a parsley cilantro aioli

Florentine Oysters
Sauteed oysters over bedded spinach with a light white wine fennel sauce

St. Peter's Fish
Pan roasted tilapia topped with cucumber, tomatoes and bell peppers drizzled with citrus vinaigrette

Shrimp Fried Lollipops
Four fried shrimp lollipops atop allumette potatoes served with remoulade and cocktail sauce


Steak Salad
Sliced filet mignon, mesculin greens, grape tomatoes, seaweed, and peanuts dressed with a Thai inspired vinaigrette

Shrimp Salad
Grilled shrimp over chopped romaine lettuce, avocado and heirloom tomatoes dressed with honey lemoncello vinaigrette

Chicken Portofino Salad
Breaded julienne chicken breast over chopped mesculin greens, fresh mozzarella cheese, cucumbers and grape tomatoes served with a balsamic reduction

Lobster Club Salad
Maine lobster, iceberg lettuce, apple wood smoked bacon and tomato tossed in a light thousand island dressing

Cobb Salad
Grilled chicken and apple wood smoked bacon over a blend of mescluin greens & iceberg lettuce served with crumbled bleu cheese, avocado, hardboiled egg, cherry tomatoes, and green olives dressed in red wine


Jimmy's Bloody Bull
Our Signature Drink; Absolut Vodka, Beef Broth, Tomato Juice, Worcestershire Sauce, Fresh Lemon Juice

Violet Eyes
Absolut Citron, Cointreau, Blue Curacao, Cranberry Juice, & Lemon Squeeze

Devil's Delight
Absolut Vanilia, Frangelico, & Lemon Juice
Served in a Sugar Rimmed Glass

French Martini
Grey Goose Vodka, Cointreau, Chambord & Pineapple Juice

Tanqueray Rangpur Gin, Cointreau, Splash of Lime & Strawberry Puree

Absolut Raspberry Vodka, Cointreau, fresh Lime & a splash of Cranberry

Easy Rita
Patron Silver Tequila, Cointreau, & Fresh Lime Juice Served in a Salt Rimmed Glass

The Governess
Stoli Ohranj, Champagne, Raspberry Puree

Cool with a Kick
Crop Organic Cucumber Vodka, Lime Juice, & Strawberry Puree

Smirnoff Apple Vodka, Sour Apple Liqueur, Cointreau and a Splash of Sour

Very Berries
Stoli Blueberri, Absolut Raspberi, Cranberry Juice and Strawberry Puree

The Orchard
Grey Goose L'Poire, Smirnoff Apple, Absolut Citron, & Mango Puree

El Fresco
Finlandia Lime Vodka, Licor 43, Cointreau, & Fresh Lime Juice

Martini Colada
Absolut Vodka, Malibu Rum & a Splash of Pineapple Juice

Eye Opener
Van Gogh Double Espresso, Stoli Vanil, Bailey's, & Creme de Cocoa served in a Chocolate Laidened Glass

Chocolate Martini
Absolut Vanilla Vodka, Tia Maria & Godiva Chocolate Liquor served in a Chocolate Laidened Glass

Jimmy McCluskey's Delight
One of Jimmy's Grandfather's favorites brought over from the 1932 menu; Mount Gay Barbados Rum, fresh Lime Juice & Sugar

Tell us about a price change or addition to this menu


One of the best steakhouse's on Long Island. Great food, friendly staff, entertaining bartenders. Always a buzz no matter what night you pick to visit. Reviewed by Matthew.

A bit to loud and crowed at the bar on Thursdays especially when they have that singer and band, That you can't even hear the person next to you. But the food is very good and the bartenders are fun.
My advice is to go on a Sunday when it's not that busy. Have the Gorganzola bread to start, it's out of this world. And their Crab Cakes are delish.
Reviewed by Robert

Map and Directions
Jump to: Top of page    Menu    Reviews    Map